Culture · Architecture & everyday journeys
How Escalators Changed the Underground
From Earl’s Court in 1911 to Piccadilly Circus, interwar art and the habits of a moving crowd.
The steps arrive already moving. There is a brief adjustment of balance, the handrail takes your hand, and the platform disappears behind you. For a minute or so the railway carries you without a train. Above, a rectangle of light promises another level of London.
The Underground’s escalators are usually treated as the space between the interesting things: the station façade, the tiled platform, the carriage. Yet the moving staircase helped change what a deep station could be. It joined engineering to architecture and made a shared journey out of the awkward business of changing height. Its story runs from Edwardian novelty through interwar art to an experiment in commuter behaviour.
A railway needs a way down
A Tube map is a flat object. The journey it represents is not. An interchange may look like two intersecting lines, but a passenger must get between the street, a ticket hall and platforms at different depths. Trains are only part of that connection. A railway that moves people efficiently along a tunnel still has to deliver them to it.
The London Transport Museum’s anniversary chronology places hydraulic lifts alongside the opening of the City & South London Railway in 1890. This was London’s first deep-level electric Tube railway, running between Stockwell and King William Street. The same chronology records the Underground’s first escalator at Earl’s Court in 1911.[1] Those two dates describe different answers to the same problem. The lift offers a compartment which comes to you; the moving staircase offers an arrival point which keeps supplying steps.
There is a revealing difference in the experience. A lift journey has a shared beginning and end: doors close on a collected group and open on another floor. On an escalator, neighbouring passengers can join a few seconds apart. The machinery makes their separate arrivals into a procession. It is possible to understand something of the station simply by watching that procession enter and leave it.
Earl’s Court and the moving staircase
The Wolfsonian–FIU, discussing an escalator print in its collection, independently dates the first Underground installation to Earl’s Court in 1911. It makes a useful distinction: London had encountered moving staircases earlier, at Harrods in 1898.[2] The Underground adopted a machine with a life beyond the railway. A device associated with a department store became part of the daily journey.
It is tempting to turn an early installation into an instant revolution. That would flatten the history almost as thoroughly as the Tube map flattens the city. Earl’s Court supplies a starting point for the Underground, not a date on which every passenger began travelling in the same way. Stations had different layouts and constraints. The more useful question is what the escalator allowed designers and travellers to imagine.
The name “moving staircase” remains wonderfully exact. It offers a familiar object with one altered property. A stair normally waits for the walker; here the stair does the travelling. The passenger must negotiate the transition between a fixed floor and moving steps, then give up some control over the pace. A mundane act becomes an encounter with a public machine.
Piccadilly Circus: a station rebuilt around flow
At Piccadilly Circus the change became an architectural project. Historic England describes Charles Holden’s 1925–28 rebuilding of the original 1906 station by Leslie Green. The replacement arranged an elliptical ticket hall beneath the Circus, with street subways and an escalator route towards the platforms. The listed complex includes its concourse and bronze entrance metalwork.[3]
The resulting sequence matters as much as the individual machine. A traveller comes off the pavement into a hall, makes a choice, and descends. The ticket hall is a place to distribute people before they reach the narrower routes below. Seen this way, architecture is doing some of the work commonly attributed to the escalator. It gives the moving stream a place to form.
Holden’s hall also complicates the idea that efficient transport must be visually bare. Historic England records travertine, bronze work and original directional lettering within the design.[3] Durable surfaces, signs and movement belonged to one public interior. The decoration was encountered by people on their way somewhere, rather than by an audience standing still before it.
This is a rewarding station to consider as a sequence of thresholds. The contrast is between street and underground, then a relatively open hall and a directed descent. The escalator is the hinge. Its effectiveness depends on what has happened before the first step and what space is waiting after the last.
Testing a station before it existed
A contemporary account in the Electric Railway Journal, published on 16 March 1929, records the rebuilt Piccadilly Circus station’s opening on 10 December 1928. It describes the challenge of construction beneath a busy junction while keeping street traffic moving.[4] The railway was not working on a blank sheet. The public city overhead remained part of the engineering problem.
One detail in the account brings that problem down to human scale. Full-sized models made with scaffolding and cardboard were used to try arrangements of escalators, landings and passages. Components could be moved while the design was being tested.[4] Long before a finished wall or handrail met a passenger, there was a temporary version of the journey.
That is an unusually vivid way to picture transport planning: a station temporarily assembled as something you could stand inside. A drawing can show a clear route while leaving its bodily experience uncertain. A landing must accommodate an arriving person, a decision and the next movement. The full-sized experiment acknowledged that a successful connection had to be more than a line on a plan.
The same contemporary report notes that the street subways could also be used to cross the Circus without buying a railway ticket.[4] That detail enlarges the station’s role. Its passages served a pedestrian who might never descend to a train. A place designed to organise railway movement could also become part of the street network. The distinction between a transport building and a piece of the city was already becoming difficult to draw.
When the escalator became an image
Cyril Power found a different kind of pattern in the moving staircase. His colour linocut Whence and Whither?, dated around 1932 by the Wolfsonian, turns descending commuters into repeated forms. Curator Shoshana Resnikoff reads the print as an uneasy view of the mechanised city: access and speed coexist with confinement and anonymity.[2]
The escalator is particularly suited to that tension. It connects people while arranging them in a visible order. Looking along the slope, one sees a sequence of heads and shoulders rising or falling with the steps. Each passenger has a private destination, but the machine briefly gives them a common rhythm. That observation is an interpretation of the journey, rather than proof that all commuters felt the same thing.
Power’s print does not need to be a diagram of an escalator to tell us something about it. The repetition is the subject. A mechanism built to solve a practical railway problem can also become a way of thinking about modern life. The art and the engineering ask different questions of the same descent.
Holborn and the habit of standing
A century after Earl’s Court, the escalator was familiar enough for a change in how passengers used it to become an experiment. TfL’s Commissioner’s Report of July 2016 described a six-month standing-only trial on two Holborn escalators nearest the Central line platforms. It explained the local problem: few people chose to walk up the long escalators, leaving much of the left side unused. An earlier test had carried about 30 per cent more people when both sides were used for standing.[5]
The report describes signs, footprints, handprints, announcements and a talking projection among the ways of explaining the arrangement.[5] These were attempts to alter an established public habit. The machine itself did not need a new direction of travel; passengers needed a different understanding of the space available.
The researchers’ paper, presented at the 2016 Lift & Escalator Symposium, reports increased capacity and reduced congestion during the pilot. It also says that the safety data were statistically insignificant.[6] That distinction is essential. A capacity result is not evidence that an arrangement has proved safer. Nor does a result from one busy station establish the best arrangement everywhere.
The interesting cultural question is how a personal choice relates to a shared flow. Walking may shorten one person’s ride while unused steps elsewhere affect the queue. Holborn made that relationship visible enough to test. This historical experiment is not a substitute for present station instructions: on a journey, follow the signs and staff directions in front of you.
Movement is not the same as access
The escalator’s promise has a limit. A moving stair is still a stair, and its presence does not establish a step-free route. A history written only around the number of passengers moved would leave out people for whom that route is unavailable.
TfL’s 2015/16 annual report offers a useful counterpoint at Greenford. It describes an incline lift travelling beside the escalator and stairs, and identifies it as the first such installation at a UK station. The purpose was to provide a step-free option. The report also notes that this solution would not suit every location.[7]
The juxtaposition is telling. Two machines can follow a slope and offer very different journeys. The important question is whether a passenger can make the complete connection they need, including the parts beyond the machine. The history of moving people becomes more accurate when it asks who is included in the movement.
It also changes how to look at the ordinary station interior. The most conspicuous route is not necessarily the route every passenger can use. A doorway at the side of a hall may matter more to one journey than the impressive procession in its centre. Reading the station through both routes gives a fuller account of its design. Movement is measured in passengers, but experienced by individuals; those two perspectives need to remain in the same history. The distinction matters even on a journey of only one or two stops.
The journey between the trains
The escalator belongs to the Underground’s history at several scales. Earl’s Court marks an early adoption; Piccadilly Circus shows how a station could be organised around circulation; Power gives the descent an unsettling human pattern; Holborn turns habit into a subject for measurement. None quite contains the others.
For the traveller, those histories occupy an interval which may scarcely register. The train has gone, the street has not yet arrived, and there is a brief journey on a diagonal. Look back from the landing and the staircase is still producing the next steps. London’s railway continues in the space between its trains.
Notes and Sources
- London Transport Museum, Underground 160 heritage chronology (2023) — 1890 hydraulic lift access; 1911 Earl’s Court escalator.
- Shoshana Resnikoff, “Cyril Power’s Escalator Print”, The Wolfsonian–FIU, 20 May 2021 — Earl’s Court and Harrods distinction; collection object Whence and Whither?, c.1932, 83.4.10; curatorial interpretation.
- Historic England, List Entry 1226877: Piccadilly Circus Underground Station Booking Hall Concourse and Bronzework — Holden’s 1925–28 rebuilding, plan, materials and listing.
- “London Underground Completes Extensive Station at Piccadilly Circus”, Electric Railway Journal 73(11), 16 March 1929, pp.439–440, transcribed by nycsubway.org — Contemporary opening account, full-sized planning models, construction and public pedestrian subways.
- Transport for London, Commissioner’s Report, 19 July 2016, printed pp.46–47 — Historical Holborn trial, local rationale, capacity and communication methods.
- Celia Harrison, Neera Kukadia, Paul Stoneman and Grant Dyer, “Pilot for Standing on Both Sides of Escalators”, 6th Symposium on Lift & Escalator Technologies (2016), pp.111–120 — Primary pilot report; capacity result and statistically insignificant safety data.
- Transport for London, Annual Report and Statement of Accounts 2015/16, printed p.25 — Greenford incline lift and the location-specific nature of the solution.
Sources checked 12 November 2026. Historical experiments are described in their original setting, not as current operating instructions. Observations about the traveller’s experience are the author’s interpretation.
Related reading: The Piccadilly Line at 120 and Moquette: The Fabric of the Underground.